The TCL C8L is without doubt one of the most intriguing Mini-LED TVs to reach our lab this year. It stands out above all for an excellent price-to-performance ratio. TCL has already got us used to aggressively priced screens, but with the C8 series the company pushes that even further. At a price that would typically only buy a mid-range model—or possibly two models like the C8K—here you get features and specs on par with top-tier sets. A new image processor, four full HDMI 2.1 ports, support for extreme refresh rates and huge peak brightness thanks to a very large number of dimming zones are hard to ignore.
That said, looking at the whole picture, we need to be honest about this TV’s character. The C8L is built more to deliver a “spectacular” image than a rigorously faithful one. What do we mean? The software and algorithms controlling the Mini-LED backlight zones are tuned to favour showiness, so the picture is bright, contrasty and strikingly saturated. And what does that mean in practice? The TV tends to interpret the image on its own rather than stick to certain studio standards. For most users seeking bigger thrills from films or games, that effect will be a plus. By contrast, purists and fans of perfectly natural images (people like us 😉) may find it too aggressive and at odds with the director’s intent. So we’ll leave the final judgement on that to you.
Overall, despite this character, the TCL C8L is a TV we can, and in fact must, recommend with a clear conscience. It’s above all a premium product that gets practically everything right, almost to the point of pain. We’d treat certain imperfections simply as characteristics of the set rather than faults—mainly because of technological limits that all Mini-LED TVs from every manufacturer have already taught us to expect. Ultimately, software polish has done a lot for the new C8, giving us a mature, assured and nearly complete TV.
The idea behind The One series has remained practically unchanged for years, and with the Philips PQS9001 this is both an advantage and its biggest weakness. Once again, we get a versatile mid-range TV whose main distinguishing feature is Ambilight. The lighting that follows what is happening on the screen can completely change the atmosphere of an evening movie session, and for many people it will be the main reason to choose this TV. That is hardly surprising, because once you get used to the effect, it can be difficult to go back to watching without it. The picture quality itself is good, but we have already seen a very similar level from this series in previous years. The VA panel provides decent blacks, colours are nicely saturated, and the brightness is sufficient for comfortable viewing in a typical living room. It is a shame, however, that Philips did not take another step forward and introduce at least basic local dimming. In a dark room, blacks can look noticeably bluish, and HDR, while clearly visible, does not make as strong an impression as it could. After so many years of The One being on the market, we would have expected a little more progress here.
There has, however, been a noticeable improvement in Titan OS. Compared with last year, and especially with the version from two years ago, the system has become much more pleasant to use. There are more apps, many smaller functions have been improved, and a number of irritating bugs we previously complained about have been fixed. Overall, it works reasonably well, although we are once again frustrated by the remote control, which still requires you to point it directly at the TV. Philips continues to rely on infrared for regular navigation, even though voice control uses a wireless connection. That makes it even harder to understand why the same connection was not used for navigating the menus. The One also has quite a lot to offer gamers. Four HDMI 2.1 ports and a broad set of gaming features are one thing, but what impressed us most was the panel’s response time. Our unit showed practically no visible smearing, even on dark backgrounds, which is quite rare for an LCD TV with a VA panel. Philips deserves a lot of credit for that. The ability to play at 4K 144 Hz or Full HD 240 Hz also makes the TV an interesting option for PC users. Unfortunately, there is still one unfinished element: using Dolby Vision in games on Xbox results in very high input lag.
The PQS9000 therefore leaves us with mixed feelings. It can surprise with excellent motion handling and shows that Philips has clearly worked on its operating system, but we do not see a similar step forward in picture quality. This is a TV we can recommend primarily to fans of Ambilight. If that lighting system is the main reason you are considering a Philips, then buying The One makes a lot of sense. It is still worth checking, however, whether you can find a Mini LED model with good local dimming at a similar price. Such a TV may offer deeper blacks and more impressive HDR performance. In the end, the choice comes down to what matters more to you: the atmosphere created by Ambilight or better picture quality itself.